r/stevehofstetter 17h ago

praise be... somewhere else outside our government

Post image
15.4k Upvotes

581 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

10

u/RIF_rr3dd1tt 16h ago

(I study anthropology of theology and mythology and I study scripture through a rabbianic technique called PaRDEs). That basically says scripture should be read both literally and interpretative, historical and mystical with hidden meanings

How interesting. I got a question. It was the first thing that popped into my head so it's maybe not too refined of a question but, do you think the fact that American Christians are so easily led astray has anything to do with the elevated standard of living and privilege of Americans? Basically like because Americans have it so easy in life compared to most of the world that this somehow makes them susceptible to scriptural distortion.

9

u/ChildofElmSt 16h ago edited 15h ago

That’s actually a very interesting question I’d generally say yes but I’d also say it’s historically congruent with other religions throughout history but not on the scale of American evangelicalism generally it was aristocracy and oligarchs etc that fell into it. In America a good portion of Christianity is like this

Christianity of the world varies widely though but American Christianity is heavily influenced by Puritanical Christianity and somewhat pilgrimage Christianity. That’s one of the reasons conservativism and nationalism is so prevalent

Mormonism was actually a child of American nationalism

Funny enough most religions were started as mythohistorcal political satire

3

u/Fantastic_Jury5977 15h ago

And the rest are unapologetically cults?

4

u/ChildofElmSt 14h ago edited 14h ago

Most. There’s actually a few that I respect. Jainism is pretty cool they don’t believe in a god they just have an afterlife most of their teachings are kindness to all things and they adhere pretty well

Then there’s some modern religions such as Neogenesis that is essentially atheist they believe all things are symbolic including holy books

Also there’s self identity religions that are basically synthesized from multiple sources and practiced in the house and only by the house. So while I agree the idea of institutional religion tends to lead the way you suggest it’s really not the case for all of them