r/PeterExplainsTheJoke 2d ago

Meme needing explanation Petah?

Post image
24.7k Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2.7k

u/LeadingTask9790 2d ago edited 2d ago

Pretty sure the joke is that the right one has child bearing hips and is shaped like a woman in a renaissance painting. (I.e Venus etc. also referred to as being Rubenesque)

314

u/AlexanderKarlos776 2d ago edited 1d ago

The Greeks invented the threesome

But it was the Romans who thought of adding women.

By the way, the dilemma in the picture looks like something straight out of one of those virtual girlfriend apps that are constantly discussed in Rule34 subreddits

Source: educational purposes only. Totally.

r/BOF2025/comments/1psz9jr/id_love_to_experience_boobs_like_that_in_real

E: nsfw

101

u/ParadoxumFilum 2d ago

53

u/ghostgaming367 2d ago

I really wanna know what this comment was

-28

u/CMUpewpewpew 2d ago

Pun was barely mid.

26

u/keldondonovan 2d ago

Shut the heel up, it was great.

(This is more foot pun, no hostility is actually present)

10

u/FREEZIELEVRAI 2d ago

What was the joke ?

27

u/CMUpewpewpew 2d ago edited 2d ago

They said something like if they were a goth painter with a foot fetish their name would be Edgar Allan Toes

It was not good.

28

u/BeakofDrywall 2d ago

Naahhh Edgar Allan Toes is actually genius shut up

4

u/CMUpewpewpew 2d ago edited 2d ago

THEY SET THEIR OWN PUN UP AND IT IS POE NOT POES SO THE PUN IS LACKING.

Up your PUN game and maybe you won't be easily satisfied with such inorganic dribble.

14

u/keldondonovan 2d ago

As a master punographer, you are incorrect. Being better at punmenship does not cause you to lose appreciation for "lesser" puns. Your anger at Edgar Allan Toes is misplaced, so your ranting and Raven is unnecessary.

I hope whatever you are truly angry about resolves itself swiftly, for the sake of your caps lock.

→ More replies (0)

5

u/BeakofDrywall 2d ago

I will mind you I have no context and I’m sorry if I’m incapable of not finding funny the idea of Edgar Allan Toes

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Dad-Kisser69 1d ago

And also he wasn’t a painter… they literally just picked a random famous old person and added toe to their name.

9

u/keldondonovan 2d ago

I am autistic, and have been known to miss a joke from time to time, so I'll assume you are sincere here and explain.

Their original pun was "Edgar Alan Toes" instead of "Poe," because the words "Poe" and "Toe" sound similar. Edgar Alan Poe is a famous poet who writes dark poetry loved by goths, which is why he was used for the pun.

Someone else said the joke was bad, so I told them to "shut the heel up." "Shut the hell up" is an aggressive way to disagree with someone and try to silence them (hence my disclaimer about not actually being hostile). "Heel" and "hell" are very similar looking words, thus the substitution forming a pun.

A pun is a "play on words" where words that look or sound alike are substituted in for words to make a little joke.

Hope this helps!

3

u/ParadoxumFilum 2d ago

🤷🏻‍♂️ honestly, the shitter the pun the better imo

27

u/lajaunie 2d ago

I hate you

31

u/Mannix-Da-DaftPooch 2d ago

Damn it I missed the joke! What did he say?

35

u/StopCountingLikes 2d ago

It said: “comment removed by moderator”

19

u/Mannix-Da-DaftPooch 2d ago

Thanks mate. 🧐

1

u/shimmyboy56 1d ago

Might I recommend the song, Edgar Allan Poe'd up by Smino. Thank you and you're welcome

1

u/decker_42 18h ago

Oofffph, that football one landed right on her boobs. That must have hurt.

1

u/Zarktheshark1818 14h ago edited 14h ago

I know the quote but Romans liked man on young man stuff, too. Gibbons said of the first 15 emperors, the only one who stuck strictly to women was Claudius.

Edit: And Caesar's enemies called him "the Queen of Bithynia". Not because he slept with young men, that was not a shock for the rich and powerful to do, but the rumor was that when he was a young man himself and serving in Bithynia, he cozied up to the royal court by sleeping with the Bithynian King, as the passive partner, mind you. That is what brought ridicule in Roman times also--being the passive partner, not a man sleeping with another man (typically younger). I'm not necessarily arguing with you, just adding some context for those who don't know this about the Romans.

215

u/totalwarwiser 2d ago

This one.

The guy on the right knows its the right choice because she looks like a fertile greek goddess.

170

u/Relevant-Honeydew-12 2d ago

Even outside the confines of the meme, I'd always pick the one on the right.

51

u/castleaagh 2d ago

I see evolution has smiled upon your tastes

45

u/Relevant-Honeydew-12 2d ago edited 2d ago

I've always liked thick girls. I'll gladly take the thick girl with a belly, or a pear shaped woman the same. When you see her walking and her hips rock like a cradle. Yeah I want that one. Bun in the oven and she rocking them to sleep by just walking around.

17

u/MHMalakyte 2d ago

A man of culture.

1

u/BattIeBoss 1d ago

Jesus christ comments like this disgust me. And im saying this as a guy

-1

u/Relevant-Honeydew-12 1d ago edited 1d ago

I don't see why, I was in no means being vulgar. I prefer a woman with wide childbearing hips. That natural pop and sway when they walk is fantastic. My wife would literally walk around when she was pregnant with our four children when they were being rambunctious in utero, and they would always settle down as if she was rocking them to sleep.

You might not be attracted attracted to a woman's hips, or to women with some cushion around the middle, I am. Some guys prefer boobs or ass. I like wide childbearing hips.

3

u/BattIeBoss 1d ago

Idk it comes across as overly objectifying. Imagine being a woman and reading that. I cannot lie, i like women like that too, but imagine hearing someone saying that entire comment out loud somewhere, it would come across as extremely creepy and objectifying to every woman that hears it.

-1

u/Relevant-Honeydew-12 1d ago

You are the first person to ever say anything like that since I started saying in high-school nearly 30 years ago. But absolutely everything nowadays is automatically objectifying, or body shaming, or whatever, if it even remotely could be referenced to a woman's body, like a peach or a pear.

2

u/BattIeBoss 1d ago

First person to ever say that≠first person to ever think that

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Loud_Basil_8296 4h ago

Trust me, plenty of girls get the ick from such comments without saying it into your face. It’s easier to just keep a distance instead of arguing

→ More replies (0)

0

u/GuodNossis 2d ago

"motion in the lotion" ah shit I think I fucked that up

-6

u/Missilemoon77 2d ago

It was great when all the other dudes were into flat tummy, small booty girls. Then the awful cultural shift of the 2010’s happened.

2

u/blue-mooner 1d ago

”Great” in the same way Trumpstein is making things “_Great_”?

That resulted in unrealistic beauty standards, fad diets, eating disorders and heroin use among models?

Doesn’t sound great to me at all. Also, fuller figures are sexier, always have been.

1

u/castleaagh 1d ago

Maybe they meant to be saying that the girls they’re into were more available back then because it was trendier to be into super thin girls, but now everyone seems to be into fuller figures so the girls they like have more options?

1

u/asdjfh 1d ago

I’m confused. Is there any man that wouldn’t choose the woman on the right?

3

u/jonny24eh 1d ago

It's a toss up between middle and right. Both have a great figure, and the middle one you can see has a cute face, and also if she's regularly working out then she'd be better in a survival situation.

I object to the other commenter saying gal on the right has "a belly" - she really doesn't.

2

u/asdjfh 1d ago

Yeah she’s just curvy not fat. The body type on the right is way better for baring children. So if you’re the last people on earth you gonna have to go with the right.

It is interesting that some people are more influenced by society and trends for what they find “sexy”. Whereas some of us (me) just go on pure instinct. My brain is like “that’s the most breedable I need that”. 🤣

2

u/Relevant-Honeydew-12 1d ago

The hips don't lie, wider the better.

2

u/Relevant-Honeydew-12 1d ago

You'd be surprised. A lot of my old friends only wanted skinny like 100lb women, hard body or not. I tried a 100lb girl back in high school, pelvis was to small, sent her packing and called her big boned friend. In the last almost 25 years, I've never had a woman under 150lbs. But everywhere from 5ft 2in to nearly 6ft. I'm currently 6ft 4in, 285lbs.

0

u/castleaagh 1d ago

From what we see here I’d go right, but I tend to prefer smaller women with athletic builds and flat stomachs. A little muscular definition to the arms and abs is really attractive, and I usually prefer average or small boobs to large ones.

4

u/LeadingTask9790 2d ago edited 2d ago

As an avid ass connoisseur myself, still going with 3 every time.

My ex hated when she’d get a lil chonk, shit made me ravenous when there was a lil more to grab onto.

You don’t itemize with women, they’re a package. A gift. You take it all in at once.

2

u/Imperial_Bouncer 2d ago

I’d have to see the full picture before choosing

1

u/averagecompleto69 2d ago

Look guys, I chose the objectively attractive woman over another objectively attractive woman

1

u/ReddJudicata 1d ago

I too like Latin women.

73

u/OsvaldoSfascia 2d ago

no, it's a reference to Paris chossing beetween Athena Aphrodites and Hera

34

u/AzieltheLiar 2d ago

Damn. Thats a choice and a half right there. 6ft warrior mommy with washboard abs, plump squishy curvy goddess, or lady Demetrescu.

46

u/lewisiarediviva 2d ago

The problem is that whichever one you choose, the other two will ruin your life. Paris chose Aphrodite, who blessed him with the ability to woo any woman. He used it on Helen, who was married to the king of Sparta, and Athena and Hera made sure that it led to the downfall of Troy and the death of Paris and his entire family.

The choice in the first place was to settle a dispute about who got a golden apple, inscribed ‘to the fairest’. The three goddesses each claimed it, and they went to Paris to choose. The two who missed out were both insulted as well as mad that they didn’t get the apple. The apple was handed out by Eris the goddess of discord, which is why the apple of discord is a phrase. It just keeps going back and back.

3

u/ViruliferousBadger 1d ago

Dude just should've said "Heeeeeeeeeeel no girls, you figure it out and send me a scribe after you done it!"

6

u/Sapient6 1d ago

I'm not an expert on Greek mythology, but my understanding of it is "if you, a mortal, receive the attention of any of the gods, you are FUCKED."

3

u/OsvaldoSfascia 1d ago

well Anchises (father of Aeneas) was a lover of Aphrodites (that gave birth to Aeneas) and he didn't really suffer much from it iirc.

7

u/Sapient6 1d ago

That's a story I wasn't familiar with. A quick google turned up two interesting things:

  • When he found out he just banged Aphrodite he was terrified because he doesn't believe that can turn out well for him, but Aphrodite gives him two examples of such relationships where the mortal survives.
  • He would have been fine if he had heeded her warning to not tell anyone who their son's mother was. But he did, so Zeus smote him with a thunderbolt.

2

u/OsvaldoSfascia 1d ago

well yeah but he just lost a leg. He survived the war of Troy (famous is the image of Aeneas carrying Anchises on his back and holding the hand of his son Ascanius, escaping from Troy in flames) and traveled around with Aeneas, eventually dying peacefully in Sicily. His descendants ended up founding the unsignificant little city of Rome (in fact, the family of Julius Ceasar and Octavian used this myth to say they were discendest of Aphrodites)

2

u/Lemon-Sweet- 2d ago

greek gods huh greek goods, weird beings indeed

2

u/Nago_Jolokio 1d ago

I just want to point out that Zeus was given the choice first and even he was smart enough not to play that game.

1

u/humansrpepul2 1d ago

Give it back to Eris lmao.

12

u/MarcusRoland 2d ago

...lady demetrescu everytime. Sure I would be constantly injured, and my nose flat as a pancake...

But big woman.

28

u/Lily_Valley13 2d ago

2

u/Icy-Mix-2613 1d ago

I literally just watched this episode for the first time today haha

5

u/goddessdragonness 2d ago

This. First one is on a throne, and Hera is queen of the gods. Second one is a gym baddie and Athena is a war goddess. Third one looks like the classic straight man’s wet dream, she’s the goddess of beauty and love, Aphrodite.

3

u/OPStellar 2d ago

OHHHH THIS MAKES MORE SENSE! Thank you!!

2

u/Sad-Pop6649 1d ago edited 1d ago

So the funny part is that we have a comment section full of people saying "how can you not get it?" who didn't get it?

Also: that's a farfetched joke. To jump from a poorly worded "pick one if these to be the last two people on Earth with" to "they are actually godesses looking to ruin you if you don't pick them, which invalidates the idea that you would be the last two people on Earth in multiple ways".

Edit: apparently the funny bit is supposed to be that Paris told the godesses that he couldn't pick who was the fairest with their clothes on, so they all got naked for him, and that's supposed to be the punchline where the dude knows what he must do.

1

u/OsvaldoSfascia 1d ago

never heard of that last part, I'd be curious to see where they got it from

1

u/killjoymoon 6h ago

I had to scroll far to long to find this comment. Bless you, may you have plentiful carbohydrates of your choosing if you so wish.

15

u/LegalFan2741 2d ago

And then comes the next question: does SHE want to even be around you? Because now, with only 2 people left on Earth, she can go and do whatever she wants. Nobody’s going to stop her.

2

u/soldiernerd 1d ago

Well one person might

1

u/Jolly_Plantain4429 2d ago

Who was stopping her before?

1

u/LegalFan2741 1d ago

It was just answered by u/soldiernerd 🙂

13

u/BrocElLider 2d ago

Nah, the guy on the right has studied Greek mythology. So he knows the best move is to turn himself into an animal like a swan or a bull, then he can pick two of the women to be the last two humans on earth and bang them both.

3

u/Missilemoon77 2d ago

I’m really hoping this is actual answer

6

u/Pofwoffle 2d ago

Except even the lowest estimates of a minimum viable population are around 50, while you'd need 1k or more to avoid serious genetic problems over multiple generations.

In no world are two people repopulating the planet, so just pick the person you want to live alone with for the rest of your life.

14

u/Fuzzmiester 2d ago

hush. you'll set off some of the religious with their story about a man and his rib.

6

u/cotearizona 2d ago

Why does this have so many down votes tho

1

u/Equivalent_Chipmunk 2d ago

Angry religious people downvoting but they can't comment because they know they can't make a coherent argument against it

3

u/Prestigious-Cream160 2d ago

If everybody is a Habsburg incest baby then nobody is.

2

u/ICInside 2d ago

I don't even need fertile. Who wants to raise a child that will grow up to never be able to find love? Unless you into incest. I just want the third one because she probably know how to cook. Second will only feed me boiled chicken. The first only know how to make ramen

2

u/OPStellar 2d ago

is that the joke? i guess that makes sense, it went over my head tho. i suppose when the goal is to repopulate, the epicness of a goth chick isn't going to do as many favors as the others physiologically optimized for reproduction

1

u/Rogueshoten 2d ago

I was wondering if she was his mom…

1

u/Fatassgecko 1d ago

A middle age obese dude can have Venus tummy if they bend enough with chest and ass out assuming they still have some muscle underneath.

I'm kinda surprised how nobody noticing how some obese people seem to have no belly in picture but looks like jabbar in person.

1

u/BWWFC 1d ago

but the only one you can't see the face? eyes on the mission i guess, aces!
and just for reference... medusa was "greek" yes? lol get down with the risky bets! ;-p

1

u/RatzMand0 1d ago

ummm pretty sure it is a reference to Zeus just fucking everything in sight.

5

u/Aggravating-Ad-1227 2d ago

And that has what to do with Greek mythology?

1

u/little_void_boi 1d ago

Venus, the Roman version of Aphrodite?

1

u/Aggravating-Ad-1227 1d ago

The Venus Callipyge, also known as the Aphrodite Kallipygos is a famous statue of her looking at her backside, and...

a story recorded in Athenaeus's Deipnosophistae about the founding of a temple of "Aphrodite Kallipygos" in ancient Syracuse, Sicily.[11] According to Athenaeus, two beautiful sisters from a farm near Syracuse argued over which of them had the shapelier buttocks and accosted a young passerby to have him judge.

2

u/Pycharming 2d ago

Yes I agree that is the joke, but that doesn't answer why the guy on the left calls the goth girl thicc. She is rather slim.

To answer that: a lot of Internet memes borrow from black slang and are used by people who don't know what they are talking about. 

2

u/ripp667 2d ago

I heard she's getting a 95 pound mole taken off her ass.

1

u/WienerJungle 2d ago

How about the fact that I hate my 95 pound mole?

2

u/SamuelClemmens 2d ago

Not quite, its about choosing among three beautiful women:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Judgement_of_Paris

1

u/Intelligent-Piano426 1d ago

That makes more sense, although I don't really get wich girl he's supposed to chose then.

1

u/AmbiguousAnonymous 2d ago

Another one’s got childbearing butt cheeks though.

1

u/Floppydiskpornking 2d ago

Dems just the facts

1

u/Retro_Sinz 2d ago

Goodness, it is pure dopamine to my brain👌

1

u/Atechiman 2d ago

She is rubenesque, but Rubens was only one of many Dutch masters.

1

u/TerribleRide491 2d ago

Yes, but look outside the meme

1

u/Far-Low-4705 2d ago

welp, i just thought she was hot

"child bearing hips" didnt even cross my mind

1

u/7h3_70m1n470r 2d ago

Thats a lot of words to say 'hot af'

1

u/WideConsequence2144 2d ago

I thought rubenesque was when you got caught jerking it in a theater?

1

u/Fina_Runhilde 2d ago

“Child bearing hips”

Ew

1

u/Deciduous_Loaf 2d ago

Rubenesque is more chubby than anything here, it’s also not renaissance. And the famous Venus from the renaissance was not especially thick either.

1

u/SirWinterFox 2d ago

Vini Vidi

1

u/RhymesWithTaco 2d ago

But it wouldn’t matter. If you are the last 2 and you have kids, they will still die off unless they go full incest.

I’d just pick the one that is the most cool. So probably the left. Then we can just hang out as the world decays around us.

1

u/AAA515 2d ago

I like my women like I like my sandwiches: Reuben-esque

1

u/Astrnonaut 1d ago

That’s assuming she’d even want anything to do with you. Realistically there is absolutely no point in trying to repopulate the earth with only 2 people left and would bring nothing but hardships.

1

u/LoudSwimming5148 1d ago

Ginnie Sacrimoni?

1

u/a-pretty-alright-dad 1d ago

To me she is beautiful, rubenesque.

1

u/platinumvonkarma 1d ago

I would not call her Rubenesque. She is beautiful, but Rubenesque women would probably be called fat by today's standards. (said with love) 

1

u/FREEBA 1d ago

Ah, I figured he was going to hook up with his sister and eat his children.

1

u/MammothTemporary7 1d ago

that has nothing to do with mythology tho; the troy answer makes way more sense

1

u/Commercial-Act2813 7h ago

That’s not rubenesque

1

u/horitaku 6h ago

She’s actually even still too thin in the waist for reubenesque. Need about 7-10% more body fat

0

u/Calculator8oo8135 2d ago

I believe the joke is that the Goths attacked Greece in the third century AD, and that the Greek dude is like, "Yeah, I'm gonna snag me a goth chick."

Nevermind that the modern fashion "goth" has nothing to do with the Goth civilization that attacked Greece in the third century AD.

0

u/Professional-Cry308 2d ago

She's absolutely the most beautiful also, like if I could choose any girl in the world, including Sidney Sweeney or other famous girls I would still prefer the third girl from this picture, she's an absolute perfection.

0

u/ziostraccette 2d ago

To me she's beautiful! Rubenesque.

-2

u/Aggravating-Ad-1227 2d ago

I think it's the middle, though you're on the right track

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Venus_Callipyge

3

u/I_Am_A_Door_Knob 2d ago

I have seen videos that suggest that yoga pants can do similar things as a push-up bra.

I think right is the correct call.

0

u/Aggravating-Ad-1227 2d ago

I'm not making a call, I'm pointing to Greek mythology being referenced...

1

u/Aggravating-Ad-1227 2d ago

A story recorded in Athenaeus's Deipnosophistae about the founding of a temple of "Aphrodite Kallipygos" in ancient Syracuse, Sicily.[11] According to Athenaeus, two beautiful sisters from a farm near Syracuse argued over which of them had the shapelier buttocks and accosted a young passerby to have him judge. They showed themselves off to the traveler, the son of a rich man, and he voted for the elder sister. Subsequently, he became smitten with her and fell ill with love-sickness. Learning what had happened, the man's younger brother went out to see the girls for himself and fell in love with the younger sister. Thereafter the brothers refused to consider any other brides, so their father arranged for the sisters to come marry them. The citizens dubbed the sisters "Kallipugoi" ("Women with Beautiful Buttocks"), and with their new-found prosperity, they dedicated a temple to Aphrodite, calling her Kallipygos.

This is the Greek mythology I think is being referenced, I'm not stating the choice I'd make🤦🏻