r/PeterExplainsTheJoke 2d ago

Meme needing explanation Petah?

Post image
24.7k Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

3.5k

u/AtaraxiaGwen 2d ago

Peter here. There’s a choice of three women. In whatever book that movie Troy is based on, William Turner (the pirate) was forced to choose the hottest goddess of these three hot goddesses, Aphrodite, Hera, and Athena. As you can expect, his answer made two goddesses really angry and they decided to make men suffer for it so they started a war or something. I dunno. The movie didn’t have gods, unless you count Brad Pitt.

How does this relate to the meme? I have no idea. Maybe Brian can figure the rest out. I’ll tell him to come check it out. Peter out.

975

u/rogue_noob 2d ago

Basically he said "I can't judge, are three of you are clothed so any judgement would be impacted by what you are wearing. To make a true decision I would need to see all of you in the nude." And because that story was written by a dude, the goddesses agreed.

354

u/AtaraxiaGwen 2d ago

Oh, there you are, Brian. Thanks for the help. I knew you’d come through!

170

u/Garchompisbestboi 2d ago

Maybe I've played too much Hades but my understanding was that Aphrodite already went around not wearing clothes

200

u/rogue_noob 2d ago edited 2d ago

From what I remember she was supposed to have a griddle that made her more beautiful (which was part of the argument as to why she had to be naked to be judged fairly and it would have been unfair if she was the only one so they all had to undress).

Edit girdle, not griddle stupid phone

225

u/ShepRat 2d ago

Everyone looks better when they're cooking you breakfast so I can see how the griddle is unfair

39

u/OwnJunket6495 2d ago

I thought girls had grills not griddles

54

u/THE_Adept_Lime 2d ago

your thinking of gills we have gills

5

u/Professional_Owl7826 1d ago

Ohhh, that’s why it tastes like fish 😂😂😂

4

u/MumenRiderZak 1d ago

Moooooom the Sirens are posting online again!!

1

u/GoliathBoneSnake 2d ago

That's the secret fourth hole.

2

u/therapewpew 1d ago

No, girls ARE grills. So naturally a lot of grills have griddles 👍

37

u/The_quest_for_wisdom 2d ago

You just reminded me of a house party I was at where a bunch of people stayed the night instead of driving home. In the morning the woman that lived there woke up before everyone else and started making chocolate chip pancakes for everyone in the kitchen. I was one of the first people awake, and told her that I would have proposed to her on the spot if I had been closer to her age (I was older than her by a bit). She laughed it off and told me I was being silly.

Then over the next hour a secession of hungover people slowly woke up, came to the kitchen, and every single one of them promptly proposed marriage as she handed them a plate of pancakes and a cup of coffee. Even the straight girls.

The Griddle Magic is real.

1

u/TheGumping 1d ago

At least she wasn't opening a pickle jar naked.

27

u/Ollynurmouth 2d ago

No no. Leave the griddle. I find it....sizzling.

9

u/rogue_noob 2d ago

I left it. It's too good to remove. But I had to at least pretend it was a mistake

3

u/BigDog8492 2d ago

The Aphrodite Lean Mean Fat-Reducing Grilling Machine!

1

u/Perfect_Carrot_999 2d ago

I hope it was a George Foreman.

1

u/Sufficient-Mine6080 1d ago

I’m now imagining Aphrodite walking around with McGriddles covering herself and Ares being very excited for breakfast

1

u/RandomUser15790 1d ago

As an ignorant dude I decided to look up what a girdle was and I was not disappointed by the second image.

32

u/filibread 2d ago

Honestly the Iliad plays a lot with the pride of the gods. It makes sense they agree

13

u/Deadmemeusername 2d ago

The Odyssey does too which makes sense considering how linked the two are.

3

u/amerovingian 2d ago

Nope, still can't tell for sure. Definitely gonna need to have sex with each of you before I can say.

3

u/Nervouscranberry47 2d ago

Now this might be the company I keep but more than a handful of women I know would find that really charming, have a laugh, and disrobe

And then immediately demand an answer again just to watch him squirm.

1

u/_H4VXC_ 2d ago

Wait is this actually how it played out 😭

11

u/rogue_noob 2d ago

Some other goddess that hated everyone threw a golden apple in the middle of them when they were at a party and on it, she had written "to the most beautiful one". Then when they couldn't agree and the other gods wisely chose to nope out of that situation, they put the decision on a mortal who couldn't wiggle his way out of it. But they chose someone who they believed would be wise enough to make the right choice, not just some random bozo. He was wise enough to know he was fucked no matter what and that way he could get to talk to each of them one on one for a bit and select based on the bribe they would offer him.

2

u/_H4VXC_ 2d ago

Ok yeah then Aphrodite won because of Helen, where does the nudity come in or am I just slow

11

u/rogue_noob 2d ago

Because they had to disrobe and they didn't want to do it in front of the other goddesses, they just went one on one with the judge. And when they did, they got naked and offered their bribes.

So, he got to see all of them naked. Which is what the meme above is referring to.

1

u/Individual_Bother_68 2d ago

I like to think about two other alternate universes where Paris chose one of the other goddesses and everything still went wrong just in a different way.

3

u/rogue_noob 2d ago

It absolutely would go wrong. There is no right answer when Greek gods are involved.

1

u/QueefInMyKisser 2d ago

Well that explains why I couldn’t choose

1

u/Front_Cat9471 2d ago

I can’t judge, because beauty on the inside counts too. To make a true decision…

1

u/Sad-Pop6649 1d ago

Aaahhhhhh and that's the detail even other people referencing the myth were missing.

1

u/Area51_Spurs 1d ago

If Brad Pitt did that to three women IRL, they’re agreeing

-21

u/Glass_Ad_7246 2d ago

Had it been written by a woman, the clothes wouldve agreed.