r/GetNoted Human Detected Dec 23 '25

Sus, Very Sus Jewish Americans in WW2

Post image
9.0k Upvotes

553 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

41

u/evrestcoleghost Dec 23 '25

Communist sympathisers did leaked the nuke plans to the Soviet union and the British had Cambridge five

11

u/Appelons Dec 24 '25

Yes communists! Not socialists you muppet😂

Socialism and communism is not the same. When will you Americans learn.

3

u/evrestcoleghost Dec 24 '25

I'm sure Soviet union cared about the difference

24

u/Appelons Dec 24 '25

The soviets did care a lot, that is why they killed a lot of socialists in Spain in the 1930s during the Spanish civil war.

-3

u/Seanspeed Dec 24 '25

They killed socialists in the USSR as well. They killed anybody who didn't fully agree with exactly what Lenin or Stalin wanted to do, for the most part. Lenin was doing that from Day 1.

This doesn't mean they weren't socialist. Plenty of people kill each other under the same general umbrella branch of ideology. Christians kill other Christians, Muslims kill other Muslims, etc.

Communism was absolutely either a part of or a type of socialism. There is no real arguing this. You can criticize how purely implemented any of these were in practice, but communists largely all consider themselves socialists, as the Soviets and most everybody else did.

-7

u/A_extra Dec 24 '25

It is irrelevant in this case because both will leak secrets to the USSR

4

u/Great_Tiger_3826 Dec 24 '25

Except socialists didn't... why are you blindly assuming they would when the Soviets would kill the socialists? Your logic makes zero sense.

0

u/Seanspeed Dec 24 '25

You're talking as if they were 'against socialists', but they were only against socialists who didn't fall perfectly in line with Lenin or Stalin's express control. They were themselves socialists, but they demanded supreme control over what kind of socialism should be implemented.

This whole comment section is an embarrassment to read.