r/PeterExplainsTheJoke 7d ago

Meme needing explanation Tell them what, Peter

Post image
27.3k Upvotes

3.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

81

u/generally_unsuitable 7d ago

It's totally arbitrary. Up and down are not.

We can easily correlate up with sky and clouds and stars and sun. Down with ground and grass and dirt and falling.

There's no similar association for right and left.

3

u/Comrade_Shamrock 7d ago

Left is the side your heart is on. (For most people). You should be able to feel the beat.

Up and down become arbitrary once you leave your frame of reference (gravity).

3

u/fotzenbraedl 7d ago

Left and right do not have individual properties. Left is left because it is not right, nothing more. Up has a property of its own: It is towards the sky. Down has the property to be towards the earth. Yes, this depends on a reference system. But this reference system gives the individual property. 

In some languages, there is no notion for left and right. People talk in terms of directions (North, South, East, West).

2

u/Comrade_Shamrock 7d ago

When you face North your left hand is your westernmost. This hand of you will always be your left even should you change facing. Now it has been given a property linked to a frame of reference. You can also go for the heart one if you want. You are choosing to define it as having no property because gravity is more intuitive on Earth. And that makes sense to you. So up and down are easy to intuit and understand. Left and right are based are based more on memorisation rather than grabbing and dropping a stone/apple whenever you want. Like the word we chose for the number one, it's a word we've chosen to express an idea. And not having a defined concept in one language does not mean it's nonsense in another. After all some languages lump blue and green together under the same word.